|
A question often asked of us during the current market downturn is:
"Where are all the distressed business opportunities?" It is a good
question because there are certainly very few businesses being marketed
by brokers at present. Those firms that are up for sale are, in the
main, smaller, less mature businesses which would always struggle in
the challenging economic climate we find ourselves in.
The distressed opportunities that qualified, experienced purchasers
are looking for are quality businesses, which may be struggling to keep
afloat solely because of the debt levels they were saddled with going
into the recession. You may recall that, in those halcyon days, the
big four (Australian) banks were fighting each other to lend money to
business owners and purchasers all throughout the decade until the tap
was turned off in spectacular fashion in early 2009.
If you purchased a business, or borrowed for expansion in late 2007
or 2008, your business would almost certainly instantly break the covenants
you agreed to when you took on the loan. Now - in most cases - there
would be very little wrong with the business at all, but the owner would
have to focus on how s/he can hold off their bank long enough to ride
out the recession. His/her eye would not be focused on developing the
business, but rather on creating any number of reports each week to
satisfy the voracious bank.
The lenders, in this type of environment,
are likely to overreact to any cashflow problems, however short-term,
and may well force the sale or liquidation of an otherwise perfectly
sound business.
How did we get here? Because of the competition between the banks since
the turn of the millennium, and the near two decades of boom times before
and after then, the banks were often lending 100% of the purchase price
of a business and, via debtor finance packages, any working capital
needed as well.
Because money was very easy to get, and
cheap, there was real competition between buyers and this drove up the
business sale price being asked and achieved. So businesses were being
sold to purchasers at elevated prices and, in a lot of cases, up to
and over 100% financed; it doesn't take much of a downturn for firms
in this situation to very quickly begin to sink under their debt levels.
To make matters worse, the global recession originated with the banks
and their frankly dodgy lending practices. Lenders were quick to shut
up shop, leaving their credit departments to again rule the roost to
scale back all previously agreed covenants – causing lots of business
owners throughout the world to lose significant amounts of sleep and
hair.
In many cases there was nothing fundamentally wrong with these businesses;
they just carried too much debt!
We have, over the last two years, tried to make contact with the troubleshooter
who sits between the shop window and the bank's dreaded collections
department. We have offered the bank our expertise in introducing these
troubled business owners to experienced purchasers, who have either
the cash or equity to buy-in or buy-out the business owner well before
s/he loses everything.
It may not surprise you to learn that these intermediaries are not interested.
The banks would rather pass the perfectly good business on to the blood
suckers, receivers and liquidators to bleed the carcass dry and let
an otherwise solid business bite the dust.
Why would they do this? Maybe it is just the tried and true method which
covers the banker’s posterior? Even by the stage it gets to the receivers
and liquidators, there would still be something to salvage if they cared
for anything but their billable hours.
A forced sale almost always leads to
a destruction of value. A good business broker will work to optimise
the value of your business.
I note that the government is currently
looking at the issue of those who currently have the responsibility
for liquidating businesses. Its proposed Insolvency Practitioners Bill
would allow the registrar of companies to ban those deemed unfit to
carry out liquidations, voluntary administrations and receiverships.
I should also say that I have dealt with a couple of very decent receivers/liquidators
over recent times, but they are in the great minority if our experience
is anything to go by.
If you talk to any experienced business
broker who has had dealings with the liquidators and their ilk, they
have been told very succinctly to mind their own business. That’s
even when the brokers want to discuss a business that they had successfully
sold in the past, and could help sell again. The liquidators point out
they have been appointed by the first secured creditor, namely the bank.
So another perfectly good business has gone, the owners’ lives are
ruined and, in most cases, the only people to be paid are the liquidators,
the receivers and those at the bank. It would be interesting to quantify
this destruction of wealth to the overall domestic economy.
Wouldn't it be sensible to first gauge if there is an appetite for the
business in the market before it is passed onto these organisations?
It not only makes logical sense, but moral sense as well.
We have numerous cashed up buyers that would step into the breach and
buy these businesses. The current owners wouldn't lose their shirts;
the banks would, in most cases, limit their losses and alleviate the
pressure on their reinsurers by having the business back within acceptable
covenants.
Not all businesses will be saleable, but let's try to save the ones
that can be sold.
|